Chris Blizzard posted a story on Planet Mozilla last night that is sure to cause concern for Comcast high speed internet customers across the country. You may remember that the federal government slapped Comcast down for throttling back users who downloaded from torrents. The company has decided that it will place an overall 250GB/month download limit on its customers rather than limiting any one type of download.
The new limits, which will go into effect 1 October, actually won’t mean a lot for 99% of their customers, according to the cable company. They have posted some comparisons on their FAQ of what it will take to reach the new limit.
To reach 250 GB in a month, for example, a customer would have to do any of the following:
- Send 50 million emails (at 0.05 KB/email)
- Download 62,500 4 MB songs (at 4 MB/song)
- Download 125 standard-definition movies (at 2 GB/movie)
- Upload 25,000 hi-resolution digital photos (at 10 MB/photo)
The big problem is that people who use streaming video, such as watching videos on Amazon, Netflix or the new WB.com website, will have a better shot at hitting the limit each month. And Chris points out that they didn’t have a calculation for YouTube and Hulu vids. As Cnet’s Josh Lowensohn writes, services like Carbonite and Mozy that let you backup your hard drives online will also help people reach their monthly bandwidth limit.
Comcast states that the first month you hit the limit you’ll be contacted by the company, but if it happens again within a six-month period they will loose their net connection completely for a calendar year.
I’ll admit when I first saw this story I was pretty ticked, especially in light of Comcast’s ad campaign for their faster high-speed connection, but as I looked into it more and discussed it with the roomies I realize we may not have that much to worry about. Unfortunately there’s a question on their FAQ about any usage monitoring tools that isn’t very helpful at all.
How does Comcast help its customers track their usage so they can avoide exceeding the limit?
There are many online tools customers can download and use to measure their consumption. Customers can find such tools by simply doing a Web search – for example, a search for “bandwidth meter” will provide some options. Customers using multiple PCs should just be aware that they will need to measure and combine their total monthly usage in order to identify the data usage for their entire account.
In other words, they’re just limiting your total downloads. Their subscribers are on their own to figure out how much they actually download each month.
Both of my roomies play MMORPGs, so we’re concerned about the amount of bandwidth that will get sucked up by Lord of the Rings Online. And of course with Ubuntu Intrepid currently in late beta stage it could affect my plans to help beta test the next release. Each update that gets downloaded for either LOTRO or Ubuntu, as well as for my roomies’ Windows computers, will add to our total bandwidth usage.
In the coming month the roomies will try to figure out how much bandwidth their MMOPRGs consume and see if it’s possible to download patches to one computer to share with the other. I, of course, will have to carefully watch my download of updates to Ubuntu Intrepid in the coming month. Since the cap goes into effect after September I suspect I’ll be grabbing the testing version of Intrepid once it leaves alpha stage and make a point of getting as up to date as possible before 1 October.
It almost makes us want to switch ISPs, but the only real alternative for us is Verizon DSL, and we’ve already taken our business elsewhere due to their rate increases, unreliable connection, and horrible customer service. In fact we left Verizon to switch to Comcast, so we may be up a certain creek with nary a paddle to navigate.